Understanding the Downsides of Impact Windows

Impact windows are a significant investment, especially for homeowners in hurricane-prone regions like Florida. While they offer superior protection against severe weather and potential break-ins, they do come with certain drawbacks. In this post, we’ll explore the downsides of impact windows by discussing their lifespan, comparing them to hurricane shutters, assessing their value, and addressing issues such as fogging. This information will help you make an informed decision about whether impact windows are the right choice for your home.

Impact windows, also known as hurricane windows, are designed to withstand high winds and flying debris during storms. Constructed with multiple layers of glass and a special interlayer that holds the glass together even if shattered, these windows provide enhanced security and peace of mind. However, like any home improvement product, impact windows have their own set of disadvantages that must be considered. This post aims to provide a comprehensive view of the potential downsides of impact windows.

Lifespan of Impact Windows

The lifespan of impact windows is a critical consideration for homeowners. Typically, these windows are built to last between 20 to 25 years. However, several factors can affect their durability, including the quality of materials, installation process, and exposure to environmental conditions.

One major downside is that the materials of impact windows can degrade over time due to continuous exposure to harsh weather conditions like intense sunlight, heavy rain, and salty air. The interlayer holding the glass together may become less effective, and the frame materials can corrode or weaken. Regular maintenance and inspections are necessary to keep the windows in good condition, which can add to ongoing costs.

Additionally, once impact windows reach the end of their lifespan, they often need to be replaced entirely, unlike regular windows where only the glass or minor components might be replaced. This full replacement can be expensive and inconvenient, potentially offsetting some initial benefits.

Impact Windows vs. Hurricane Shutters

When considering the downsides of impact windows, it’s important to compare them with alternative protective measures like hurricane shutters. Both provide storm protection, but they have distinct differences that can influence a homeowner’s choice.

Hurricane shutters are generally more cost-effective than impact windows. They are less expensive to purchase and install and can be removed and reinstalled as needed, offering flexibility and ease of maintenance. This makes them an attractive option for homeowners on a budget or those looking for a temporary solution.

However, hurricane shutters have their own negatives. They require manual operation, meaning homeowners must be present to deploy them before a storm, which can be a hassle for those who travel frequently or might not be home during a storm. Additionally, shutters can block views and reduce natural light when deployed, making the home feel darker and less open.

In contrast, impact windows provide continuous protection without manual intervention and offer better insulation and noise reduction, enhancing overall home comfort. However, their higher initial cost and potential for decreased effectiveness over time are significant considerations.

Are Impact Windows Worth the Investment?

Deciding whether impact windows are worth the investment involves weighing their benefits against their drawbacks. One major advantage is their continuous protection against severe weather and potential break-ins, which can lead to lower home insurance premiums.

However, the high upfront cost of impact windows compared to traditional windows or hurricane shutters can be a deterrent. Additionally, the potential need for future replacements and ongoing maintenance costs must be factored in. It’s important to calculate long-term savings from reduced insurance premiums and increased home value to determine if the investment is justifiable.

Another consideration is the aesthetic impact. Impact windows do not require additional fixtures like hurricane shutters, which can improve the home’s appearance. They also allow for unobstructed views and natural light, enhancing the living experience. Despite these advantages, the financial burden and maintenance requirements remain significant drawbacks.

Do Impact Windows Fog Up?

Fogging is a common concern with impact windows. This issue occurs when moisture gets trapped between the glass layers, causing condensation and obstructing views. Fogging can be both an aesthetic and functional problem, making it a key point in discussing the negatives of impact windows.

Several factors can contribute to fogging, including poor installation, which can create gaps and leaks that let moisture in. The quality of window sealant and materials also plays a role; over time, the sealant may degrade, increasing the risk of moisture infiltration.

To mitigate fogging, it’s crucial to invest in high-quality impact windows and ensure professional installation. Regular inspections and maintenance can help identify and address potential problems early. Despite these preventive measures, fogging remains a potential issue, underscoring the importance of understanding the downsides of impact windows.

Conclusion

While impact windows offer numerous benefits, including enhanced protection and improved aesthetics, they are not without their drawbacks. The lifespan of impact windows, their comparison with hurricane shutters, their value as an investment, and the potential for fogging are all critical factors to consider. By understanding these downsides, homeowners can make a more informed decision that aligns with their needs and budget.

If you are considering impact windows for your home, it is essential to weigh these negatives against the benefits carefully. For those ready to take the next step, we invite you to schedule a free in-home impact window consultation today. Our experts can provide personalized advice and help you determine the best solution for your home, ensuring you make a well-informed decision.

More Post Like This

GET STARTED WITH A

Free Consultation

Check Out Our Reviews

Eric Wendt
Eric Wendt
January 12, 2024
Read More
If there was a 10 star they would get it. The attention to detail and quality was beyond anything I could have imagined. This is by far the best contractor we have experience in Florida.
Melissa
Melissa
July 25, 2023
Read More
Karoly was a very professional company overall. The installation crew did a fabulous job, such a nice new addition to our home.
H Young
H Young
April 4, 2023
Read More
I love my new windows and doors. It makes the house feel warmer, while the outside temp is in the 30's. Plus, the outside noise has reduced, greatly. Karoly and team did a great job from the initial estimate visit, to the office communications, and then the installation team. All professional and knowledgeable. Everything went smoothly and very impressive to watch.
Mary Talley
Mary Talley
March 18, 2023
Read More
Excellent customer service, from start to finish. Everyone is super friendly from the office to the installers. The installation crew was awesome. Very clean when installing the windows, awesome work. Prices are very good for quality installation. Big thanks to Karoly Windows and Doors. I highly recommend and I will use them in the future for when I replace my exterior doors.
George Rourke
George Rourke
March 11, 2023
Read More
Karoly Windows and Doors is a great company, very professional & extremely pleasant to work with. We had our sliding glass doors installed, along with a few other windows. The service provided was beyond our expectations. Highly recommended. Looking forward to doing business with Karoly Windows and Doors soon.
Gloria McCall
Gloria McCall
February 17, 2023
Read More
We were very pleased with the work done by Karoly Windows and Doors. The Simonton windows and sliding patio doors transformed the look of our house. I would absolutely recommend them to a friend and we look forward to doing work with them in the future.
Curt Garcia
Curt Garcia
February 10, 2023
Read More
Excellent service, very responsive and professional service. Karoly Windows and Doors installed everything perfectly and the county inspector said this was a good install and was done perfectly. Very high-quality work. Highly recommend Karoly Windows and Doors. One of the best window companies near me in Clearwater!!
Bruna Firmino
Bruna Firmino
January 25, 2023
Read More
If you need impact windows and exterior doors for your house, call Karoly Windows and Doors. They do exceptional work and treat their customers right. We love our new double hung replacement windows and impact doors. Highly recommended!!!
John Tilghman
John Tilghman
January 16, 2023
Read More
Excellent experience with Karoly Windows and Doors. The hurricane impact windows are extremely high quality. The installation team was thorough and they cleaned up well after installation. Highly recommend!

Trusted by the Biggest Brands

Inspiration Gallery